When the last figure depends on the pair before it
Every figure in these questions is cut into the same parts: two halves, four quarters, or the four sides of a square. Nothing turns, moves or counts up. Instead, what the third figure shows in each part depends on what the first two figures show in that same part. White and grey might give black; grey and grey might give white. The grid never prints the rule. It shows you the pairs, and you read the rule off them.
It looks impossible until you treat it as a lookup table: the same pair in gives the same fill out, every time, in every part of the figure.
How to think about it
- Spot the signal. The figures are split into the same parts in every cell, and the fills seem to shuffle with no direction. No turn, mirror or count step explains it.
- Read one part across row one. Take the left half: first figure, second figure, third figure. Write it down as a pair and its result: “white and grey give black”.
- Build the table from the two complete rows. Do the same for every part of rows one and two. The same pair always gives the same fill, whichever part it sits in, so a few entries cover the whole grid. Order matters: grey then white can give something different from white then grey.
- Fill in the missing figure part by part. For each part of row three, look up its pair in your table. Decide the whole figure before you look at the options.
- Check the direction. Most questions read along the rows. Some read down the columns, and the hardest use a table in each direction. Use the direction whose complete lines give a table that never contradicts itself.
The traps
Each wrong option is a mistake that is easy to make here:
- A rule of thumb. “The darker one wins” or “keep the first” fits some pairs and not others. If one pair breaks it, drop it.
- The pair the wrong way round. You looked up grey and white when the part shows white, then grey.
- One part left out. Every part is right but one, which just copies the second figure. Check every part, not most of them.
- A copied neighbour. The figure beside the gap, or the one above it. It is offered because it looks familiar.
- The wrong row of the table. One part takes the result of a pair that shares only one fill with the right one.
- The other direction’s table, on questions that use one table along the rows and another down the columns.
The Method’s chapter on conditional rules, with fixed totals and one feature deciding another, is the advanced lesson of the Matrix Reasoning course.